What better way to recover from the Black Friday madness than by supporting local toy stores in our charming towns. We’ve rounded up the most adorable stores that not only house this year’s trending toys but are filled with memorable shopping experiences. We could all use a break from our screens to get out there in person and support the livelihood of those who help keep the wonder of childhood alive this season! (Not ready to ditch the screen time yet? No problem. Almost all stores on this list accept online orders).
All Together Now – 16 Main Street, Tarrytown & 53 South Moger Avenue, Mt. Kisco
When word spread that the only toy store in Tarrytown was closing this year, residents were heartbroken. Fortunately, it was replaced by another amazing toy store in the same location! With two locations now, Tarrytown & Mt. Kisco, All Together Now is more than just a toy store – it’s a resource for kids and parents alike. A place where they understand that community happens at all scales and offer a location to shop, learn, express, and create. In-person and curbside pick-up is available.
The Briarcliff Toyshop – 1171 Pleasantville Road, Briarcliff Manor
They are offering specialty and educational toys, Legos, games, and arts and crafts.
Miller’s In Mamaroneck – 335 Mamaroneck Avenue
An outrageous selection of the best toys, bikes, clothing, shoes, and play equipment for your kids.
Penny & Ting – 133 Main Street, Ossining
Carefully selected toys, books, and games for children. The winner of Westchester Magazine’s Best Of 2019 & 2020. Shop online and in-person.
Tom’s Trains – 686 Saw Mill River Road, Ardsley
Searching for the perfect under-the-tree train this year? Got a choo-choo enthusiast? This is your place! In-person and online shopping is available.
Toy Box of Mamaroneck – 300 W. Boston Post Road, Mamaroneck
The largest independent toy store in Westchester offers complimentary gift wrapping and free parking.
NYHC Comics – 117 Main Street, Dobbs Ferry
There’s something so nostalgic about comics. They completely transcend generations. Not exactly a toy store, but definitely an amazing store for a collector in your family! In-store and curbside pick-up is available.
Learning Express Toys of Rye Brook – 14 Rye Ridge Plz., Rye Brook
Unique and educational toys that capture imaginations!
Big Top of Scarsdale – 1465 Weaver Street, Scarsdale
Toys, puzzles, and school and party supplies. Online, in-store, and curbside pick-up is available.
TP Toys And Accessories – 572B North Avenue, New Rochelle
Specializing in educational toys. Gift wrapping, in-store, and curbside pick-up is available.